Procedure for reviewing complaints regarding violations of academic integrity and publication ethics
Procedure for reviewing complaints about violations of academic integrity and publication ethics
The editorial board of the journal “In the World of Mathematics” is guided by the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the provisions of the Law of Ukraine “On Education” (Article 42 on academic integrity). The editorial board undertakes to consider all reports of possible violations of academic integrity, in particular: plagiarism, self-plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, conflict of interest, as well as disputes over authorship.
Types of violations subject to investigation:
Plagiarism: use of someone else’s texts, ideas, formulas or graphic materials without proper citation.
Self-plagiarism (duplication): re-publication by the author of his own results without reference to the original source.
Falsification and fabrication: manipulation of mathematical data, proofs or invention of non-existent results.
Violation of authorship: inclusion in the list of authors of persons who did not make a significant contribution, or exclusion of real co-authors (“guest” or “ghost” authorship).
Undisclosed conflict of interest: concealment of financial or personal connections that could affect the objectivity of the research.
Filing a complaint
Complaints are accepted in writing to the official email address of the Editorial Board.
The applicant must provide specific facts confirming the violation (for example, references to primary sources in the case of plagiarism).
Anonymous complaints are not considered, however, the Editorial Board guarantees the confidentiality of the applicant’s identity during the investigation.
Stages of investigation
Stage 1. Submission and initial audit. Complaints are sent to the editorial board in the form of an official appeal. The editor-in-chief conducts an initial check for the presence of an evidentiary base. In the case of plagiarism, specialized software is used.
Stage 2: Official investigation. If the complaint is justified, the Editorial Board creates an independent Ethics Commission. The members of the commission must not be co-authors with the participants in the conflict or work in the same institution as them.
Stage 3: Communication with the authors. The editorial board is obliged to notify the author in writing about the essence of the claim and provide the opportunity to provide a reasoned response within 14 calendar days.
Stage 4: Decision-making. The commission makes one of the following decisions:
1. Rejection of the complaint due to lack of evidence.
2. Correction: publication of a clarification if the error was unintentional and does not affect the fundamental conclusions of the article.
3. Retraction: in case of confirmation of serious violations (plagiarism, falsification). The text of the article remains on the site, but is marked with a watermark "RETRACTED" with the publication of the reason for the retraction.
4. Institutional notification: The editorial board reserves the right to notify the author’s institution or academic societies of the violation.
Appeal mechanism
The author(s) has the right to appeal the decision of the Editorial Board within 14 days, providing additional arguments. The appeal is considered by a new group of experts, whose decision is final and cannot be further appealed within the journal.
Confidentiality and data protection
All stages of the investigation are carried out in compliance with confidentiality. Information about the progress of the investigation is not disclosed to third parties until an official decision is made.